Hearthstone Lead Game Designer Ben Brode is back with another developer insights video, this time tackling the sticky topic of consistency in Hearthstone, while also touching upon the differences between digital and physical card games.
Brode admits that druid cards like Druid of the Claw and Ancient of War are a bit inconsistent in how they work. Both give a stat-boosting choice, though one is a buff while the other is a transform effect, and thus silences and return-to-hand abilities affect them differently. Brode says that that's less of an issue in the digital realm because it's better to have easily understood effects that treat "edge cases" like silences a little differently. In the physical realm, you'd need a judge at all times to interpret those edge cases, but a digital CCG comes packed with its own judge -- the game itself -- to help speed things along.
I can see that, though there's an easy solution: Change Druid of the Claw's text to include a "transform" effect, as was done with newer cards like Druid of the Flame. Brode brings up this solution himself later in the video, that choosing between "4/4 with Charge; or 4/6 with Taunt" would help consistency but negatively impact the simplicity of making a decision between "Charge; or +2 health and Taunt."
Personally, I think it's more a case of being so used to something that changing it -- even if it makes it better -- seems confusing even when it's not, and that Hearthstone players would adapt with little to no trouble, and that it would be better for the game in the long run. What do you think?
- Always Online Podcast: Did Redfall and ESO MMO Presentations Deliver, Hearthstone & A Sub, And The Day Before's Mess Ep 461
- Blizzard Wants To Know How Much Players Would Pay For A Hearthstone Subscription Via Survey
- Always Online Podcast: Blizzard, NetEase, & A Dead Orc Statue, Ubisoft Strike, & Dragon's Dogma MMORPG Returning? Ep 460
About the Author
Jason Winter is a veteran gaming journalist, he brings a wide range of experience to MMOBomb, including two years with Beckett Media where he served as the editor of the leading gaming magazine Massive Online Gamer. He has also written professionally for several gaming websites.
Warface Winter Update Revamps Maps, Adds Weapons, And More
Crytek’s free-to-play online shooter, Warface, is getting a shiny new update for the holidays.By QuintLyn Bowers - 7 years ago
You May Enjoy
World of Warcraft Classic Tech Lead Leaves Blizzard, Protesting “Stack Ranking” Employee Evaluation System
The system reportedly requires that approximately 5% of employees get a low ranking.By QuintLyn Bowers - 4 days ago
League Of Legends Source Code Stolen During Cyber Attack Last Week; Riot Receives Ransom Email
"Today, we received a ransom email. Needless to say, we won't pay."By Anthony Jones - 4 days ago
DDO 2023 Development Roadmap Reveals 17th Anniversary Plans, Mini-Expansion, And Performance Improvements
After overhauling and adding new features last year, Daybreak continues rounding out the game with fresh content.By Anthony Jones - 1 day ago
FTC Apparently Timed Lawsuit Against Microsoft-Activision In An Attempt To Manipulate A Potential EU Settlement
This does align with the fact that the FTC lawsuit came only hours after US and EU officials had a call.By Aspen Pash - 1 day ago
Disney Dreamlight Valley Infographic Confirms Multiplayer For 2023, But We're Still Missing A Lot Of Details
A long-awaited feature for the game gets no mention.By Anthony Jones - 2 days ago
Ahoy! Sea Of Thieves Enters 2023 With Matchmaking And PVP Improvements As Well As A Brand-New Adventure
Batten down the hatches and prepare for a storm of PvP battles.By Aspen Pash - 5 days ago