CCP Senior Director: Dust 514 "Failed To Contain Scope," Promises Better For Project Nova

Jason Winter
By Jason Winter, News Editor May 9, 2016
Share:

Project Nova

Over on PCGamesN, there's an interview with CCP Shanghai Senior Director Snorri Árnason, who goes into sometimes-painful detail about what went wrong with Dust 514 and how things will be different with Project Nova.

In large part, the interview comes off as sounding like Dust was planned as too ambitious, with too many moving parts than could be effectively managed and implemented. The much-ballyhooed interaction between Dust 514 and Eve Online -- especially the ability to call in orbital strikes -- never really developed like it should, and was more of a "selling point" than anything else.

"It sounds great to get an orbital bombardment between the two games - it’s a great selling point. Logistically it’s terrible. I played the game for three years, I never saw it really happening."

Despite the decline of the PlayStation 3 and rise of the PlayStation 4, Árnason doesn't think Dust on PC would have fared much better.

"It failed to contain scope, and delivered too many average features instead of few top quality ones... [Putting it on PC] it wouldn’t have fixed the inherent problems of scope versus execution."

Project Nova looks to be a more self-contained game, feeling like Eve without being shackled to CCP's iconic MMORPG or requiring a connection to it to get the full experience. The whole Dust 514 concept and execution never felt right to me or practically anyone I knew, so it's good to see CCP learning from the experience and making something with a much higher chance of success.

Share:
Got a news tip? Contact us directly here!


About the Author

Jason Winter
Jason Winter, News Editor
Jason Winter is a veteran gaming journalist, he brings a wide range of experience to MMOBomb, including two years with Beckett Media where he served as the editor of the leading gaming magazine Massive Online Gamer. He has also written professionally for several gaming websites.

Discussion (7)

Alpha 5 years ago
It failed because CCP failed to listen to their Eve player base when it was suggested to make it PC based just like Eve.
The rest of the excuses are just a superficial dog and pony show where they place the blame elsewhere instead of admitting they didn't give a damn what their players say.

Andrey Subbotin 6 years ago
The game failed before its development was even started because CCP is incompetent
* 100% of their prior audience plays on PC
* The game's only selling point was its link to EVE, otherwise its just a mediocre FPS MOBA
* and the game had no PC version

everything after that decision was a long scream on the way to the pavement

Podded noob 6 years ago
I look forward to the new iteration of the game and hope that it succeeds where it's hardware/engine limitations of the console version held it back

rickshaw 6 years ago
What makes CCP fail...
is they are in Iceland. ...its too bloody cold and they can't break any ice to escape it!
So therefore CCP freezes and so do their any ideas as they are wrapped up in blankets,..
Problem is CCP are still stuck in that EVE thing so their fishing holes are all Iced up!. lol

View 2 replies
Descri 6 years ago
What CCP said is a bunch of pure grade BS, the reason it failed, is because they literally said they were not going to support it anymore, which caused a massive slide of players out and that was at fanfest during when the game was supposed to be mid cycle. Not only that but they were completely tone deaf to bugs, along with complaints, they promised features they never planed to impliment. It took more then 2 years to just add daily quests/missions, to a lot of people Dust 514 is toxic to even mention. They did not even bother fixing bugs that they should have been till after they had already milked all the money they could out of the game. Half the time they did not even know what pricing structure they were going to use, and oh yeah, they did a massive bait and switch several times. Dust 514 failed purely due to CCP being just plainly horrid in so many ways.


You May Enjoy

Roadmap Update For Legends Of Aria Reveals Closed Alpha Testing Amid Game Relaunch

Roadmap Update For Legends Of Aria Reveals Closed Alpha Testing Amid Game Relaunch

"We will be relaunching the game with a focus on delivering the founding vision for LoA."

By Anthony Jones - 2 weeks ago
NetEase Is launching Its First U.S. Studio With A F2P Veteran At The Helm

NetEase Is launching Its First U.S. Studio With A F2P Veteran At The Helm

It has the most American name ever, Jackalope Games.

By QuintLyn Bowers - 2 weeks ago
Elyon Gets A Familiar Tank Role When The Paladin Class Drops On May 25, Free Stuff On The Line

Elyon Gets A Familiar Tank Role When The Paladin Class Drops On May 25, Free Stuff On The Line

Pre-register now and get an exclusive outfit.

By QuintLyn Bowers - 1 week ago
FFXIV Players Teleported To Jail After Using Mods During Live Broadcast

FFXIV Players Teleported To Jail After Using Mods During Live Broadcast

What is the future of FFXIV and third-party tools moving forward from these events?

By Aspen Pash - 1 week ago
Take Out Captan! Phantasy Star Online 2 New Genesis Celebrates A Year In Action

Take Out Captan! Phantasy Star Online 2 New Genesis Celebrates A Year In Action

In-game festivities kick off today.

By QuintLyn Bowers - 1 week ago
If The Warner Bros. Fighting Game MultiVersus Is As Good As Its Trailer, We’re Gonna Have A Good Time

If The Warner Bros. Fighting Game MultiVersus Is As Good As Its Trailer, We’re Gonna Have A Good Time

We’ll know soon because the Closed Alpha is on the way.

By QuintLyn Bowers - 4 days ago
See More
Live Giveaways