Swordfighting Game Blade Symphony Goes Free-To-Play, But Gameplay Update Sparks Backlash
I'm not one to blindly defend free-to-play. Some games are better with it, some are better without. And sometimes a bad game is just bad, free-to-play or not.
Blade Symphony, a PvP sword-battling game from developer Puny Human, was released in 2014 and just went free-to-play last week. The F2P update included 48 new items and a new path for unlocking items. A "Find Duel" option was added to the main menu, and Puny Human has "rebuilt duel_castle from the ground up!" That sounds cool! You can read the full patch notes here.
Now, on to the bad news. Blade Symphony is getting review-bombed, as you can tell on its Steam page. To read the news on various other sites around the internet (here's one with a particularly venomous subhead), it's getting slammed because veteran players are upset with the changes to the gameplay and the F2P switch.
Is that the case? Well, let's first take a look at the game's recent player numbers. It's pretty easy to tell when it went free-to-play:
In my opinion, if your game is averaging fewer than 10 players online at a time, you're totally within your rights to remake it in any way you want to draw in new people, even if it alienates your existing (and insignificant) fan base.
I also looked through many of the recent negative reviews and, yes, the vast majority of them were from new-ish players, with fewer than three hours in the game. The one quoted at the top of that Eurogamer article was from someone who had spent 15.6 hours in it, which rates him as a "grizzled veteran," compared to most of the others.
This doesn't mean that the reviews from new players, virtually all of whom came in after the F2P switch, should be ignored. It's entirely possible that Blade Symphony is just bad right now, but that's likely got more to do with the recent patch -- it has a 68% overall positive rating versus 33% on recent reviews -- and not because it's free-to-play.
About the Author

Jason Winter is a veteran gaming journalist, he brings a wide range of experience to MMOBomb, including two years with Beckett Media where he served as the editor of the leading gaming magazine Massive Online Gamer. He has also written professionally for several gaming websites.
Read Next
Spaceship Design MMO Exocraft Launches On Steam Tomorrow
Tomorrow, GoldFire Studios' multiplayer space mining game Exocraft will officially launch on Steam, bringing the game to a whole new audience.
By QuintLyn Bowers - 3 years agoYou May Enjoy
Yesterday It Was A Rumor, Today It Is A Fact: Rumbleverse Is Shutting Down
Iron Galaxy says we may not have seen the final form of the Rumble though.
By Michael Byrne - 2 days agoFallout 76 Announces Removal Of Illegal Weapons Mods
Some folks are about to be very unhappy.
By QuintLyn Bowers - 1 week agoThe Omega Protocol Arrives In Final Fantasy XIV’s Patch 6.31 Update
The testing continues.
By QuintLyn Bowers - 1 week agoBlizzard’s Bringing The Original Overwatch’s Credits Currency Back To Overwatch 2 In Season 3
Players will be able to purchase epic and legendary-tier skins with them.
By QuintLyn Bowers - 2 days ago💣 Feature | No, “MMORPG” and “MMO” Games Are Not Dying
But those terms are probably dead...
By Luis Dobreira - 5 days agoCWA Withdraws Request For Unionization Vote At Proletariat; Blames CEO's "Confrontational Tactics" Causing Unfair Election
A dicey situation just got worse for Proletariat workers.
By Anthony Jones - 1 week ago
Discussion (0)