UK Children's Commissions Urges Government To Regulate Loot Boxes As Gambling

Jason Winter
By Jason Winter, News Editor
Share:

Did you know that the UK had a "Children's Commissioner"? This American didn't, but it is apparently a post in the government, and the current office-holder is Anne Longfield, who "promotes and protects the rights of children, especially the most vulnerable, and stands up for their views and interests."

Today she produced a lengthy report about gaming habits of British children, titled "Gaming the System." Its purpose, as stated in brief summary on the Commissioner's website, is for the nation to make "changes to gambling laws" to account for the monetization of video games.

In the report, Longfield laid out several of the social advantages and disadvantages of online gaming, which she acknowledges as being similar to those experienced in offline activities. She does, however, call for "limiting the role of money" in games, particularly for the government to "take immediate action to amend the definition of gaming in section 6 of the Gambling Act 2005 to regulate loot boxes as gambling," as well as calling for "an additional warning to be displayed for games which facilitate in-game spending." She also suggested parents take a larger role in speaking with their children about the importance of balancing their expenditures of time and money in games.

In particular, while we tend to focus on the "pay to win" competitive aspects of loot boxes, we don't usually take into account the "competitive" aspects of cosmetics. Longfield, who engaged several children ages 10-16 in focus groups split up by game (Minecraft, Call of Duty, Fortnite, FIFA, Roblox), reported that many children felt compelled to spend money due to peer pressure or to avoid ridicule:

In the Fortnite group, children felt that they should spend money on skins to prevent being seen in the free default skin. The default skin is seen not only as making someone “uncool”, but is a marker of being a ‘poor kid’, and is therefore something to be avoided.

In closing, Longfield re-iterated her wish that loot boxes be regulated as gambling, as her colleagues in the Department for Digital, Culture, Media & Sport Committee did last month. She dismissed the "you can't cash out" argument often raised by the ESA as fallacious -- not only in the case of third-party sites that allow for such monetary transactions but also in the sense that "the argument fails to recognise the value placed by children on winning certain items, even when those items cannot be cashed out for money." Given the pressure now being put on by multiple offices in the UK, it seems inevitable that her recommendations will someday be codified into law.

Share:
Got a news tip? Contact us directly here!

About the Author

Jason Winter
Jason Winter, News Editor
Jason Winter is a veteran gaming journalist, he brings a wide range of experience to MMOBomb, including two years with Beckett Media where he served as the editor of the leading gaming magazine Massive Online Gamer. He has also written professionally for several gaming websites.

Discussion (1)

Manipulator 3 years ago
gambling~noun~the act or practice of risking the loss of something important by taking a chance or acting recklessly: RNG is gambling.. we're practically a gambler hhh


Read Next

SWTOR's Onslaught Expansion Has Arrived

SWTOR's Onslaught Expansion Has Arrived

Star Wars: The Old Republic dropped update 6.0.0 -- otherwise known as Onslaught -- today, adding new story content that ends in a dramatic flashpoint in a previously unexplored area of the planet Corellia.

By QuintLyn Bowers - 3 years ago

You May Enjoy

WoW Classic Update Kicks Off Second Phase Of Wrath Of The Lich King

WoW Classic Update Kicks Off Second Phase Of Wrath Of The Lich King

Ulduar received a lot of love.

By QuintLyn Bowers - 1 week ago
Bungie Offers Players A Look At Neptune’s City Of Neomuna Ahead Of Destiny 2’s Lightfall Launch

Bungie Offers Players A Look At Neptune’s City Of Neomuna Ahead Of Destiny 2’s Lightfall Launch

The trailer also gives players a peek at the game’s upcoming Darkness subclass.

By QuintLyn Bowers - 1 week ago
Pantheon: Rise Of The Fallen Devs Dropped A Juicy Lore Video Introducing The Nomadic Aridola Faction

Pantheon: Rise Of The Fallen Devs Dropped A Juicy Lore Video Introducing The Nomadic Aridola Faction

For all the lore fanatics out there, here's your next scoop.

By Anthony Jones - 1 week ago
Rocket League Devs Banned A "Vast Majority Of Accounts" Using Bots And Adds "Cheating" Report Reason Back

Rocket League Devs Banned A "Vast Majority Of Accounts" Using Bots And Adds "Cheating" Report Reason Back

"We will continue to monitor for bots and take appropriate action against any players/accounts using them."

By Anthony Jones - 1 week ago
NCSoft Announces Final Internal Test For Throne And Liberty, Lucky Participants To Receive Free RTX 3060

NCSoft Announces Final Internal Test For Throne And Liberty, Lucky Participants To Receive Free RTX 3060

Nothing is stopping you from applying, but unless you can get to or live in South Korea, you likely won't be picked as the test is in-person.

By Michael Byrne - 2 days ago
New ArcheAge: Unchained Fresh Start Server Will Ease Gear Progression, Tweak Boosting, And Increase Item Drop Rate

New ArcheAge: Unchained Fresh Start Server Will Ease Gear Progression, Tweak Boosting, And Increase Item Drop Rate

The developers stated the server will include many improvements based on community feedback.

By Anthony Jones - 1 day ago