Was Trion's Recent ArcheAge Scam Reversal The Right Call?

QuintLyn Bowers
By QuintLyn Bowers, News Editor March 30, 2016
Share:

archeage

When you think of scammers in video games, you might think of those people who are out to get your password and steal your account in order to sell it off bit by bit for real world money -- which will then likely be used to expand some gold farming empire. But what about those games where scams are actually a feature of gameplay?

In these games, the devs overlook things like one player cheating another during a trade deal. Tricking other players and walking away with their stuff is perfectly okay. And, infiltrating a group to rob them of everything they own is considered next level gameplay. Hell, if you’re good enough, some games -- like EVE Online -- will be telling your story forever.

eve online

Earlier this week, the news broke about Trion reversing one of these scams in ArcheAge, a game that more or less allows just this kind of villainy. A live streamer had been robbed during a trade that occurred while he was streaming for charity. The reason Trion gave for the reversal was simple; the scammer in question broke the game’s terms of service by impersonating one of the streamer’s friends.

Now, let’s get something out of the way here before we get into the nitty gritty of all this. First of all… Okay, if the player broke the ToS, fine. Trion has us there and are well within their rights to reverse the scam. It’s a judgement call… They made it. And let’s ignore the arguments about this streamer being popular and the stream being for charity. That’s not relevant to what I’m about to say here.

See… I don’t think it’s the call I would have made. As a fan of this kind of deliciously evil gameplay, I love games that allow it to happen. But I feel that if you’re going to allow “scamming,” you can’t say one kind is okay while another is not. Let’s face it. In the real world, THIS is exactly how someone might scam you. They pretend to be someone they’re not -- and even worse, someone you might actually know. It happens all the time with people trying to gain access to email accounts. You get an email that looks like it’s from Google -- or your email provider of choice -- it says that you’ve just tried to change your password and that you need to click the link to finish the process. Clicking the link takes you to a fake site where you put in your password and suddenly someone else has access to your account.

archeage 2

Now… If you’re a smart and careful person, you’re immediately suspicious. Rather than clicking on any links, you inspect the email header, see the email isn’t legit and instead navigate to your gmail via the web browser to change your password and check your security settings… Just in case. You’re smart enough to be suspicious and protect yourself.

This is where my problem lies with this reversal. If scams are allowed in a game, then it’s up to the potential scamees to be careful. Here you have someone who didn’t even look closely enough to verify that this was really his friend trying to trade with him. He just click “okay” and went on. I mean… I don’t know about you guys, but I can typically tell who my friends are in game by the way they “speak” in chat. And there is generally some sort of discussion before any trades happen. Even if it’s just, “Sup.” I’m very diligent about anything that involves me handing my hard earned goods over to someone else and am of the opinion that everyone else should be as well.

This may seem a bit harsh to some players. But from a gameplay perspective it feels like the right thing to do. Otherwise, where’s the actual risk?

archeage 3

That said, if the other player had broken into his account… Or stole his friend’s account in order to pull the scam off, I would be all for that being set right. There is a line between playing the hard game and literal cheating. But, in a game where scamming is allowed, caution should be the order of the day… and something like this should be considered a lesson learned.

Another interesting thing of note on this topic is that Trion admitted that -- as they put it -- the particular policy that prompted this reversal had "not been made public in the past." To be fair... No one ever reads the ToS. Ain't no one got time for that... So it's totally believable that this particular clause exists and has existed. It's also believable that this same call has been made before and that we're just now hearing about it because of the victim being "high profile" this time around. But, at the same time, it seems like something that should have been made common knowledge up front, considering the nature of the game.

Finally, I would like to note that despite the fact that I'm not really on board with Trion's reversal here, that doesn't make the scammer in question any less of a jerk... But then, that's pretty much the definition of a scammer, isn't it?

Share this Article:

In this article: Trion Worlds, EVE Online, ArcheAge.

About the Author

QuintLyn Bowers
QuintLyn Bowers, News Editor
QuintLyn is a long-time lover of all things video game related will happily talk about them to anyone that will listen. She began writing about games for various hobby sites a little over ten years ago and has taken on various roles in the games community.

Discussion (8)

Unknown 6 years ago
I like the game but Trion is a awful publisher which will pretty much ruin the game.

Laneneris 6 years ago
Lol I lost 400mil once to a scammer in dodixi over compressed veldspar.

KekLoL 6 years ago
From a neutral perspective, the reversal is ok in this scenario cuz there is evidence to prove the scam beyond reasonable doubt. When scams are made in games its usually very hard to prove, this is not the case.

Liveits 6 years ago
If it is in the TOS it was made public knowledge. Trion is not responsible for the player reading the TOS, that is up to the player. If the ignore the public knowledge out there and get caught breaking the TOS, that is their fault.

teppic 6 years ago
You can't ignore the fact it's a prominent streamer who's received special treatment. That's all it comes down to. Selective enforcement of terms that nobody reads clearly has nothing to do with why they did it, like any selective enforcement it was a convenient excuse to show favouritism.

Trion's reputation is already dirt, so I suppose they think on balance it's better to get more 'Trion's doing it yet again' bad press while keeping a streamer happy for all the advertising it's worth.

View 1 reply
Annonymous 6 years ago
Meh not a fan of the eve style scamming gameplay. I think Trion is in the "right" simply because trade scams and what not are hella annoying and they probably stand to lose customers more than they will gain if they allow it. However, being in the "wrong" is not so bad really, gaming needs niches and there aren't that many that allow people to play as a scammer. It's all pixels in the end, no right or wrong to me unless it involved RL.

Lagwin1980 6 years ago
Stick to the rules they enforce with no exception
If no one gets a scam reverted it sucks but it's fair
If one gets it then they should all get it.

All they have done is disgruntled a lot of players, ones that play fair, ones that have been scammed and potential new players
And they have encouraged scamming within the rules.

True people should be careful and use common sense when it comes to trading anything but common sense seems to be lacking


You May Enjoy

24 Entertainment Explains The Origins Of Naraka: Bladepoint In New Documentary

24 Entertainment Explains The Origins Of Naraka: Bladepoint In New Documentary

The action-adventure battle royale game has always stayed true to its original vision.

By Aspen Pash - 1 week ago
Cammy and Ryu Get The Bean Treatment In Fall Guys’ Latest Crossover

Cammy and Ryu Get The Bean Treatment In Fall Guys’ Latest Crossover

The Street Fighter crew joins the chaos.

By QuintLyn Bowers - 1 day ago
The Winter Soldier Joins the Marvel’s Avengers Lineup As Part Of The 2.7 Update

The Winter Soldier Joins the Marvel’s Avengers Lineup As Part Of The 2.7 Update

The update also adds new gear and a power level increase.

By QuintLyn Bowers - 18 hours ago
Epic Alleges Google Paid Activision $360 Million To Not Launch Competitor Mobile App Store, Activision Claims "Nonsense"

Epic Alleges Google Paid Activision $360 Million To Not Launch Competitor Mobile App Store, Activision Claims "Nonsense"

Epic says "Project Hug" is Google's anti-trust project, Google claims it fosters development and competition.

By Michael Byrne - 1 week ago
World Of Tanks Reveals Holiday Ops 2023: Stars Arnold Schwarzenegger, Milla Jovovich, And Holiday Village

World Of Tanks Reveals Holiday Ops 2023: Stars Arnold Schwarzenegger, Milla Jovovich, And Holiday Village

Another year, another round of resources to collect and rewards to get.

By Anthony Jones - 1 day ago
Game Design Spotlight #16: Lost Ark's Cinematic Cutscenes Unveils Zone Depth While Staying Cohesive

💣 Feature | Game Design Spotlight #16: Lost Ark's Cinematic Cutscenes Unveils Zone Depth While Staying Cohesive

The isometric perspective does more for the game's cutscenes and zones than you think.

By Anthony Jones - 1 week ago