Defiance, Warships, Trek Devs Talk About Loot Boxes In Their F2P Games

Jason Winter
By Jason Winter, News Editor
Share:

Much of the talk/controversy surrounding loot boxes lately has dealt with their recent inclusion in full-priced games, like Star Wars Battlefront II or Middle-earth: Shadow of War. Free-to-play games have, naturally, been using loot boxes for years, and a few developers of prominent F2P titles recently talked about their experiences in creating them and making them palatable to players.

Gamasutra interviewed team members of Defiance, World of Warships, and Star Trek Online to talk about how their games arrived at their current loot box systems. Their probably-carefully-worded answers cover the usual ground, about how they try to carefully balance rewards while making sure everything obtainable from a loot box is also attainable in-game without taking "an unfair amount of time," as Defiance Producer Matt Pettit says. "We think about the player-facing perspective as the priority, and the business need second. Without the first, the second doesn’t happen."

STO's Stephen Ricossa and his team "took our best guess with our initial lock box offerings," while Wargaming's Philip Molodkovets said "the backlash was strong and immediate" when World of Warships erred in adding unappealing items to its loot boxes. And all three developers have re-worked their loot boxes' graphical appeal when being opened -- whether for special events or permanently.

For what it's worth, I feel like World of Warships does a good job with how it offers loot boxes in game, and I don't recall having any issues with Defiance's implementation during the short while I played that. I played Star Trek Online for an even shorter period of time, five years ago, so I can't really speak to how that game does things, but at least it (and the other two games) don't seem to have had a "burn it all down" incident like some other games have had.

Share:
Got a news tip? Contact us directly here!

About the Author

Jason Winter
Jason Winter, News Editor
Jason Winter is a veteran gaming journalist, he brings a wide range of experience to MMOBomb, including two years with Beckett Media where he served as the editor of the leading gaming magazine Massive Online Gamer. He has also written professionally for several gaming websites.

Discussion (2)

Dabdakka 5 years ago
Ya but lately STO has been very empty.. I highly doubt that game will last much longer with only a few whales supporting them for the lock boxes since that is the only main goal to get pvp geared up. Anything else will just take way to long nearly a life time to even get up to where another player was a few months ago because they decided to dump $100's off for the loot boxes in end STO is the same example of what EA did, but EA did it in a pure MMOFPS element and not a MMORPG element in which case they would have gotten away with it if the game was similar too STO.

Why or how would they been able too is fully only based off how people would have reacted to the grind of the game where as MMORPG games typically have a long grind period and most players tend to ignore those views. While its the same exact concept players will only be willing to go so far.

Thats what they all say 5 years ago
By "balance", they mean they throw a bone just often enough to keep some free players around for the whales to play with. While also maximizing money harvested from their paypig whales.


Read Next

SkySaga Developer Radiant Worlds Picked Up

SkySaga Developer Radiant Worlds Picked Up

Back in August, Radiant Worlds was tossed to the curb by Korean publisher Smilegate, putting the future of its sandbox MMO Skysaga: Infinite Worlds in doubt.

By Jason Winter - 5 years ago

You May Enjoy

Yoshi-P: If Investigations Show Mods Used In FFXIV Ultimate Clear, "I Will Not Recognize That Team As True World First"

Yoshi-P: If Investigations Show Mods Used In FFXIV Ultimate Clear, "I Will Not Recognize That Team As True World First"

From mods in Ultimate, to leaked footage, to punishments, Yoshi-P isn't happy.

By Michael Byrne - 4 days ago
UPDATED: A Halo Infinite Survey From Microsoft Feels An Awful Lot Like It’s Throwing 343 Industries Under The Bus

UPDATED: A Halo Infinite Survey From Microsoft Feels An Awful Lot Like It’s Throwing 343 Industries Under The Bus

The survey comes after layoffs at the developer.

By QuintLyn Bowers - 5 days ago
MMORPG "The Quinfall" Is Promising A Lot Including "Adapting Real Life Into A 'Meta' World"

MMORPG "The Quinfall" Is Promising A Lot Including "Adapting Real Life Into A 'Meta' World"

That isn't the only claim the new company behind the title is boasting though...

By QuintLyn Bowers - 5 days ago
World Of Warships Legends Celebrates The Year Of The Rabbit With Dragons

World Of Warships Legends Celebrates The Year Of The Rabbit With Dragons

It’s an interesting choice, but we’re sure players are down for it.

By QuintLyn Bowers - 5 days ago
FFXIV’s Director & Producer Naoki Yoshida Says He’s “Really Looking Forward” To The MMORPG Blue Protocol

FFXIV’s Director & Producer Naoki Yoshida Says He’s “Really Looking Forward” To The MMORPG Blue Protocol

Several experienced people from the FFXIV Team are also now working on Blue Protocol.

By Aspen Pash - 5 days ago
Legends Of Runeterra 2023 Roadmap Announces New Quarterly Content Cycles, Offering A Variety Of Updates Each Month

Legends Of Runeterra 2023 Roadmap Announces New Quarterly Content Cycles, Offering A Variety Of Updates Each Month

2023 is shaping up to be a year of new additions and changes to content distribution.

By Anthony Jones - 5 days ago