UK Gambling Commission Has "Significant Concerns" About Loot Boxes, But Doesn't Call Them Gambling

Jason Winter
By Jason Winter, News Editor July 23, 2019
Share:

It seems like the UK has way too many officials who are being quoted on the subject of loot boxes in gaming. A few weeks ago, it was the digital minister, but now the people actually responsible for gambling law in the country are weighing in.

As reported by the BBC, two members of the UK Gambling Commission weighed in recently on the thorny subject of loot boxes. The commission's programme director, Brad Enright, stated that "There is unquestionably a demand for a secondary market" for items such as FIFA's player cards, posing the question to game developers, "we can see you have T&Cs [Terms and Conditions], what are you doing to apply them?" In other words, developers acknowledging that these types of things are illegal is all well and good, but unless they take action to shut down such illicit activities, it amounts to tacit approval.

The commission's chief executive, Neil McCarthur, added that there were "significant concerns" about loot boxes, but that the legislation, as it's currently written, did not define them as gambling, saying:

"There are other examples of things that look and feel like gambling that legislation tells you are not - [such as] some prize competitions but because they have free play or free entry they are not gambling... but they are a lot like a lottery."

Enright added that he didn't think it was up to the Gambling Commission to monitor video games, instead saying that "We think Valve in the US should do more." (In that case, he's probably talking more about skin betting in Counter-Strike: Global Offensive and not players in packs for FIFA, which is made by Electronic Arts.)

I'll just keep going back to my old piece about early mixed martial arts tournaments and how they weren't boxing, and therefore couldn't be regulated by the state's boxing commission. Eventually, though, they were regulated, and sensibly so.

Officials in the UK might agree that loot boxes aren't gambling, but that they "are a lot like a lottery" and they have "significant concerns" about them. Maybe the gambling commission won't regulate them, but they could be covered by a different, or entirely new, government agency that might deal with them in a way that game developers don't like very much.

Share:
Got a news tip? Contact us directly here!

About the Author

Jason Winter
Jason Winter, News Editor
Jason Winter is a veteran gaming journalist, he brings a wide range of experience to MMOBomb, including two years with Beckett Media where he served as the editor of the leading gaming magazine Massive Online Gamer. He has also written professionally for several gaming websites.

Discussion (3)

Cloak 2 years ago
UK vs Definitions.

gambling

n.
the act of playing for stakes in the hope of winning (including the payment of a price for a chance to win a prize).
v.
Present participle of gamble.
n.
An activity characterised by a balance between winning and losing that is governed by a mixture of skill and chance.

Definition = Win.

Manipulator 2 years ago
so to summarize t, it's a "legal" gambling

View 1 reply

You May Enjoy

Overwatch 2's New Dev Blog Addresses Balance Considerations And Support Character Changes

Overwatch 2's New Dev Blog Addresses Balance Considerations And Support Character Changes

Players can expect weekly updates and buffs, nerfs, and changes to Overwatch 2.

By Aspen Pash - 1 day ago
Fortnite Adds The Protector Of The Innocent, RoboCop

Fortnite Adds The Protector Of The Innocent, RoboCop

Sadly this bundle is going to cost you more than a dollar.

By Aspen Pash - 3 days ago
Swords of Legends Online's Patch 2.0.10 Brings Hard Mode Raid, Extreme Dungeons, And More

Swords of Legends Online's Patch 2.0.10 Brings Hard Mode Raid, Extreme Dungeons, And More

Including new cosmetics you can get after completing the new content.

By Anthony Jones - 2 weeks ago
Everquest II's Time-Locked Expansion Server, Varsoon, Rolls Into Beta Today

Everquest II's Time-Locked Expansion Server, Varsoon, Rolls Into Beta Today

Open for all fans to test and get an early look before its official launch.

By Anthony Jones - 1 week ago
Destiny’s Season 17 Makes Big Changes To Iron Banner And Welcomes The Return Of Rift

Destiny’s Season 17 Makes Big Changes To Iron Banner And Welcomes The Return Of Rift

Guardians also have a brand-new map to explore.

By Aspen Pash - 6 days ago
Find Out More About Phantasy Star Online 2: New Genesis’s June Update Via Interview With Hiro

Find Out More About Phantasy Star Online 2: New Genesis’s June Update Via Interview With Hiro

The interview covers the new Kvaris region.

By QuintLyn Bowers - 1 day ago
See More
Live Giveaways