UPDATE (March 10): The developers of Naïca have spoken up in their defense, repudiating the claims of Redditor gamingsec about their game’s security, particularly the accusation that account information could be easily obtained. In addition, the MMORPG subreddit mods who originally “verified” gamingsec’s claims have investigated further, saying that the passwords obtained for Naïca were re-used from compromised accounts in other games, notably Town of Salem.
It now appears that the primary error made by the developers was that they didn’t have any captchas or a limit on the number of login attempts — not that there was no encryption on passwords; they now claim to have addressed those issues. They posted a long statement about the situation on their Discord, which we’re reproducing below.
ORIGINAL STORY (March 8):
Last week, we told you about the demise of indie MMORPG Naïca, which would be going into maintenance mode just four months after its open beta launch. Since then, new details have emerged regarding the poor handling of the game’s security and its developers’ dismissal of those concerns.
Redditor gamingsec posted this morning about his interactions with the dev team and, as he put it, their “Poor Security, Worse Business Practices.” He said that he informed the developers about “a number of vulnerabilities/exploits” during the alpha in October that allowed gameplay advantages and — most concerningly — access to user account credentials. According to gamingsec, only one such issue, one that crashed the game, was ever addressed.
He initially approached the developers in private, and they dismissed his concerns by saying that “Alpha is not relevant anymore” and he should “Wait [for] the open Beta!” When he later advised players in the official Discord to change their account credentials, he said he was “met with suppression from their moderation team, who consistently delete these posts.”
gamingsec has (rightly) not made this method of access public but says it still exists in the game in its current form. He did demonstrate a currency exploit in a video.
Reddit, at least, seems to be taking the issue more seriously than the Naïca developers. A moderator replied to gamingsec’s post asking for verification of his claims, which appears to have been swiftly provided. The mod said that the /MMORPG subreddit will “look at putting a full embargo on anything Naica-related or from the same developers” while also re-iterating the recommendation to change your passwords to the game.
For what it’s worth, most of the comments seem to fall more in the “incompetence, not intentional malice” camp regarding the security and other issues with the game. Regardless of the reasons, between this and its rapid shuttering of its first game — which it accepted money for — it’s going to be very difficult for the same dev team to get positive attention for its next project.